US foreign policy and the military
Claims about American military intervention, NATO, and the defence establishment.
23 checked claim occurrences · 3 sources · 2 attributed speakers
Every claim on this topic
No claims match the selected filters.
-
The US fought a 20-year regime change war against the Taliban
The US war in Afghanistan lasted approximately 20 years (2001–2021), but characterizing it entirely as a 'regime change war' is an oversimplification; it began as a counterterrorism mission post-9/11 and evolved into a complex nation-building and counterinsurgency effort, not purely regime change.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
Sources used for this check
-
NATO didn't go around recruiting — countries came to NATO
Multiple historical sources confirm that after the Soviet Union's dissolution, Eastern European and former Warsaw Pact states eagerly and voluntarily sought NATO membership out of fear of Russia, rather than being recruited by NATO. NATO formalized this through Membership Action Plans in response to demand from these countries.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
Sources used for this check
-
Putin's actions in February 2022 provoked two new countries (Finland and Sweden) to join NATO and his borders with NATO have grown
Finland and Sweden both applied to join NATO in May 2022 explicitly due to Russia's invasion of Ukraine, and Finland's accession alone more than doubled NATO's pre-existing land border with Russia (adding ~830 miles).
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
Sources used for this check
-
The 2008 war in Georgia came 2 or 3 months after the Bucharest summit where NATO announced that Georgia and Ukraine would be entering NATO
The Bucharest summit concluded on April 4, 2008, and the Russo-Georgian War began on August 8, 2008 — approximately 4.2 months (126 days) later, not 2 or 3 months. Additionally, NATO did not announce Georgia and Ukraine would be 'entering' NATO; it stated they 'will become members' while denying them the Membership Action Plan at that time.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
Sources used for this check
-
Joining NATO was very unpopular in Ukraine around 2006
Multiple polling analyses confirm that before 2014, NATO membership had minority support in Ukraine, with public opinion especially divided between western and eastern regions; a majority of Ukrainians in that period did not favour NATO accession.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
-
Robert Gates, Robert McNamara, and William Perry were three secretaries of defense who warned against NATO expansion
McNamara and Perry did warn against NATO expansion, and Gates later called expanding toward Ukraine 'overreaching' in his 2015 memoirs. However, grouping all three as straightforwardly warning 'against' expansion conflates different roles, timings, and severity of objections — Gates's warning came retrospectively in memoirs, not as active policy opposition, and McNamara's role is less well-documented than Perry's on this specific issue. The speaker also misidentifies McNamara as 'Robert McNamara' without noting he was Kennedy/Johnson-era SecDef, not a contemporary of this debate.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
-
William Perry, the secretary of defense at the time, almost resigned over NATO expansion and said his biggest regret in life is that he didn't resign over it
Multiple sources confirm Perry nearly resigned when his advice against rapid NATO expansion went unheeded, and he expressed deep regret about the policy direction. However, the specific claim that he said his 'biggest regret in life' was not resigning is a strong characterization that goes beyond what is clearly documented in publicly available sources; Perry is documented as a strong critic and near-resignee, but that precise framing is unverified.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
-
George Kennan was the founder of the containment strategy and warned that NATO expansion would inevitably lead to conflict with Russia, predicting that when Russia responds everyone will say 'this is why we needed to expand NATO'
George Kennan is well-documented as the architect/founder of the containment strategy, and his 1998 quote to the New York Times explicitly predicted Russia would react adversely and that NATO expansionists would then say 'we always told you that is how the Russians are' — closely matching the paraphrase given in the transcript.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
Sources used for this check
-
Henry Kissinger said Ukraine would have to be a special arrangement and that Ukraine will not come into NATO
Kissinger consistently opposed Ukrainian NATO membership for years, stating flatly 'Ukraine should not join NATO' after 2014 and advocating for a neutral/buffer status. He only reversed this position after Russia's 2022 full-scale invasion, so his pre-2022 position as described in the transcript is accurate.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
-
Kamala Harris openly said that NATO was going to join Ukraine (or Ukraine was going to join NATO) shortly before the invasion
Harris did not explicitly say Ukraine was imminently joining NATO. She tweeted in a way that some interpreted as implying Ukraine was a NATO member, which she deleted, and she spoke at the Munich Security Conference in February 2022 about Ukraine and NATO unity but did not announce imminent membership. The claim exaggerates or mischaracterizes what she actually said.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
-
In 2008 at the Bucharest summit, NATO announced that Ukraine would be coming into NATO.
The 2008 Bucharest Summit Declaration explicitly stated 'these countries [Ukraine and Georgia] will become members of NATO,' and NATO Secretary-General Jaap de Hoop Scheffer confirmed it with 'not a sliver of a doubt.' No Membership Action Plan was granted, but the political commitment was unambiguous.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
-
In 2017, Donald Trump cut off the CIA program to fund the anti-Assad rebels.
Multiple credible sources, including The Washington Post and Al Jazeera, confirm that in July 2017 President Trump ended the covert CIA program to arm and train moderate Syrian rebels fighting Assad's government.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
-
Wesley Clark was Supreme Commander of the NATO forces
Clark's actual title was Supreme Allied Commander Europe (SACEUR), a specific regional NATO command, not a generic 'Supreme Commander of NATO forces.' The distinction matters because SACEUR is one of two NATO Strategic Commanders, not the singular supreme leader of all NATO forces.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
Sources used for this check
-
Clark saw the plans first in 1991 and they came from Paul Wolfowitz
Multiple sources confirm Clark described a separate 1991 conversation with Paul Wolfowitz at the Pentagon after the Gulf War, which he cited as the ideological origin of the neoconservative push to dominate the Middle East. This is distinct from but related to the 2001 memo.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
Sources used for this check
-
The highest position Paul Wolfowitz ever reached was Deputy Secretary of Defense (under Donald Rumsfeld)
Wolfowitz did serve as Deputy Secretary of Defense (2001–2005) under Rumsfeld, but he subsequently served as President of the World Bank (2005–2007), which many would consider an equally or more prominent international role. Calling Deputy SecDef his career peak omits the World Bank presidency.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
Sources used for this check
-
Wesley Clark said he first saw plans from Wolfowitz (who brought them to the national security adviser)
Clark's documented accounts describe a Pentagon memo shown to him after 9/11 originating from the Office of the Secretary of Defense, and a separate 1991 conversation with Wolfowitz. The specific detail about Wolfowitz bringing plans to the national security adviser who said 'we'll look at this after the election' is not clearly corroborated in Clark's widely cited public statements, making this a more specific attribution than what Clark is on record saying.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
Sources used for this check
-
Richard Perle was a member of the Defense Policy Board which had an advisory capacity toward the Pentagon in the early 2000s, but it was by no means a policy board that dictated Pentagon policy
Richard Perle served on the Defense Policy Board Advisory Committee, chairing it from 2001 to 2003. The board is explicitly advisory in nature and does not have direct policymaking authority over the Pentagon.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
Sources used for this check
-
Mark Steyn said you can't help thinking one of the reasons people find Wolfowitz so appealing to talk about is that his name starts with a nasty animal and ends Jewish
This specific quote attributed to Mark Steyn could not be independently confirmed in available sources. While Steyn has written about antisemitic undertones in Wolfowitz criticism and the name is discussed in that context by others, the exact wording of this quote cannot be verified.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
Sources used for this check
-
Paul Wolfowitz and Dick Perle (Richard Perle) were consequential neoconservatives in relation to American foreign policy
Paul Wolfowitz served as Deputy Secretary of Defense and is widely described as an architect of the Iraq War. Richard Perle chaired the Pentagon's Defense Policy Board and was a key advisor to Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld, also described as an architect of the Iraq War.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
Sources used for this check
-
A four-star general said that Middle East policy was driven by Richard Perle and Paul Wolfowitz (referred to in the transcript as 'Dick Pearl and Paul Wolfworth')
General Wesley Clark, a four-star general and former NATO Supreme Allied Commander, publicly described a 'policy coup' by neoconservatives including Paul Wolfowitz and others driving Middle East policy post-9/11. Clark recounted a 1991 conversation with Wolfowitz and later attributed aggressive Middle East destabilization plans to this neoconservative network. The names in the transcript appear to be phonetic transcription errors for 'Richard Perle' and 'Paul Wolfowitz', both well-documented as central neocon architects of Middle East policy.
Video Joe Rogan Experience #2303 - Dave Smith & Douglas Murray
-
Roman dodecahedra are hollow bronze or copper-alloy objects with 12 pentagonal faces and differently sized circular openings, ranging roughly from golf-ball to grapefruit size.
Known specimens are hollow copper-alloy dodecahedra with pentagonal faces and apertures of varying diameters. Their documented overall sizes are approximately 4–11 centimeters, broadly matching that comparison, although individual specimens vary.
Video Hidden Gaps In History We Still Don’t Understand
Sources used for this check
-
The Pentagon is about to run out of money for the war within a few weeks.
Public reporting confirms that Hegseth sought urgent supplemental funding, but the available sources do not establish that the Pentagon would literally run out of money within a few weeks.
-
The Pentagon is canceling military exercises because of funding pressures related to the war.
The transcript asserts that exercises were being canceled and that Hegseth was moving funds, but the available reliable sources do not sufficiently document this specific claim or establish the stated cause.
