One of the World's Largest Gatherings You've Never Heard Of
Every claim, checked
No claims match the selected verdicts.
-
Claim 1
“another crowd, one that's larger than almost any other annual gathering on Earth, fills the streets of Iraq.”
Arbaeen is among the largest annual gatherings in the world.
Multiple academic, medical, and major-news sources describe Arbaeen as one of the world’s largest annual religious or human gatherings. The wording does not claim it is unambiguously the single largest gathering of any kind.
Sources
- 1Arbaeen public health concerns: A pilot cross-sectional survey↗
Supports
Arbaeen is an annual religious procession in Iraq with an estimated 17–20 million participants.
- 2Shiite Muslims join Arbaeen pilgrimage in Iraq amid fears of US-Iran escalation↗
Supports
Millions of Shiite Muslims observed the annual Arbaeen pilgrimage Tuesday in the Iraqi holy city of Karbala
- 1Arbaeen public health concerns: A pilot cross-sectional survey↗
-
Claim 2
“More than 20 million people travel to Karbala, Iraq for Arbain.”
More than 20 million people travel to Karbala, Iraq, for Arbaeen each year.
Academic and medical sources commonly estimate Arbaeen participation at approximately 17–20 million or around 20 million pilgrims annually. Exact totals vary by year and counting method, but the claim’s stated scale is supported.
Sources
- 1From Attachment to a Sacred Figure to Loyalty to a Sacred Route: The Walking Pilgrimage of Arbaeen↗
Supports
In this regard, Arbaeen has become the most important Shia pilgrimage in the world by attracting the highest number of pilgrims (around 20 million domestic and foreign pilgrims).
- 2Assessment of Temporary Community-Based Health Care Facilities During Arbaeenia Mass Gathering at Karbala, Iraq↗
Supports
In Iraq, millions of people gather annually on the 20th day of the lunar month of Safar in Karbala for the remembrance of Arbaeen of Imam Hussain from different countries
- 1From Attachment to a Sacred Figure to Loyalty to a Sacred Route: The Walking Pilgrimage of Arbaeen↗
-
Claim 3
“For Shia Muslims, Arbain marks 40 days after the martyrdom of Imam Hussein”
For Shia Muslims, Arbaeen marks the fortieth day after Imam Hussein’s martyrdom.
Arbaeen is observed on the twentieth day of Safar, traditionally marking forty days after Husayn ibn Ali’s death at Karbala.
Sources
- 1Assessment of Temporary Community-Based Health Care Facilities During Arbaeenia Mass Gathering at Karbala, Iraq↗
Supports
In Iraq, millions of people gather annually on the 20th day of the lunar month of Safar in Karbala for the remembrance of Arbaeen of Imam Hussain
- 2From Attachment to a Sacred Figure to Loyalty to a Sacred Route: The Walking Pilgrimage of Arbaeen↗
Supports
millions of pilgrims start their spiritual journey on foot through several routes depending on their departure point ... to reach the Iraqi city of Karbala to commemorate the event.
- 1Assessment of Temporary Community-Based Health Care Facilities During Arbaeenia Mass Gathering at Karbala, Iraq↗
-
Claim 4
“the martyrdom of Imam Hussein, the grandson of the prophet Muhammad, who was killed at the battle of Gerbala in 680 CE after refusing to legitimize the rule of Umay Khalif Yazid.”
Imam Hussein was Muhammad’s grandson, was killed at Karbala in 680 CE, and refused to pledge allegiance to Yazid.
Reference works identify Husayn ibn Ali as Muhammad’s grandson and place the Battle of Karbala in 680 CE. Historical summaries also state that Husayn refused to give allegiance to Yazid after Yazid’s accession.
Sources
- 1Karbala - Encyclopaedia Iranica↗
Supports
The plain of Karbala was the site of the battle on 10 Moḥarram 61/10 October 680 between Imam Ḥosayn and the Omayyad army.
- 2Al-Hussein (5-61 AH / 624-680 CE)↗
Supports
Throughout many cities, notables refused to swear allegiance to Yazid, among them was Al-Hussein the Prophet’s grandson.
- 1Karbala - Encyclopaedia Iranica↗
-
Claim 5
“Under Saddam Hussein, urban processions were restricted and even sometimes violently suppressed. Public commemorations of Imam Hussein was also considered a political threat”
Saddam Hussein’s government restricted and sometimes violently suppressed Shiite religious processions and commemorations.
Contemporary government and historical accounts document bans or restrictions on Shiite processions and commemorations under Saddam Hussein, as well as clashes and violence against people attempting to conduct them.
Sources
- 1Saddam Hussein's Repression of the Iraqi People↗
Supports
the prohibition of certain processions and public meetings that commemorate Shi'a holy days.
- 2Joint Committee Print↗
Supports
1998 and 1999, violent incidents were reported between pilgrims on one side and Ba’th Party members and security forces enforcing the ban on the other.
- 1Saddam Hussein's Repression of the Iraqi People↗
-
Claim 6
“After Saddam's government fell in 2003, the gathering returned on a scale that the world had never seen before.”
After Saddam’s government fell in 2003, Arbaeen returned on a scale the world had never previously seen.
Sources support the lifting of Saddam-era restrictions and the revival of mass pilgrimage in 2003. They do not establish that the resulting scale had never previously been seen anywhere in the world, making that framing misleading.
Omits: The gathering was revived or greatly expanded after 2003, but the claim omits that large Karbala pilgrimages and Arbaeen observances existed before Saddam's rule and that 'the world had never seen before' is an unsupported absolute comparison.
The intensifier 'the world had never seen before' is judged as an absolute historical comparison; the narrower claim that the gathering returned and expanded after 2003 is supported.
Checked twice, independently: the first pass returned False and the second Misleading. Recorded as Misleading.
Sources
- 1IRAQ: Shia Pilgrims Progress Past Saddam↗
Supports
The pilgrimage of grief is also the first mass expression of relief over the fall of Saddam Hussein.
- 2U.S. Department of State Annual Report on International Religious Freedom for 2003 - Iraq↗
Background
In 2000, the Government issued orders prohibiting the walking pilgrimage to Karbala and reportedly deployed more than 15,000 Republican Guard troops armed with light weapons and in civilian clothes on the main roads leading into both cities to enforce the prohibition.
- 1IRAQ: Shia Pilgrims Progress Past Saddam↗
-
Claim 7
“In the 80 km leading up to Garbala, Iraqis set up thousands of temporary stations known as Moakib. Families across Iraq use this time to provide medical care, free meals, water, tea, places to sleep”
The route from Najaf to Karbala is approximately 80 kilometers, and pilgrims receive free food, lodging, and basic medical care from volunteer facilities.
A peer-reviewed study identifies the Najaf–Karbala distance as 80 km and reports that temporary community facilities provide voluntary, free food, beds, and basic primary health care. The source supports the underlying services and route length, though it does not independently verify the exact phrase “thousands” in this excerpt.
Sources
- 1Assessment of Temporary Community-Based Health Care Facilities During Arbaeenia Mass Gathering at Karbala, Iraq↗
Supports
Najaf and Karbala are neighboring governorates, and the distance between Najaf City (capital of Najaf governorate) and Karbala city (capital of Karbala governorate) is 80 km; 22 km are within the boundaries of Karbala governorate.
- 2Assessment of Temporary Community-Based Health Care Facilities During Arbaeenia Mass Gathering at Karbala, Iraq↗
Supports
They offered participants voluntary free-of-charge services such as food and bed as well as basic primary health care services.
- 1Assessment of Temporary Community-Based Health Care Facilities During Arbaeenia Mass Gathering at Karbala, Iraq↗